Why fixed step goals fail

image credit: Unsplash

Almost every step counter starts you with the same goal: 10,000 steps, every day, forever. It's simple, and for a lot of people it quietly stops working within a few weeks. Not because they're lazy, but because one fixed number is a poor fit for how people actually walk. Here's why a fixed step goal fails, what the research says works better, and how to set one that moves with you.

What is a fixed step goal?

It's one daily target that never changes: the same number on a Tuesday at your desk as on a free Saturday, the same in your first week as in your fortieth. The 10,000 default is the best-known, but a fixed 6,000 or 8,000 has the same problems. The trouble isn't the number. It's that the number doesn't move.

Ten thousand itself came from a 1965 Japanese pedometer, not a study, as the 10,000 steps guide explains. The research since points to a range that depends on your age, set out in how many steps a day you need. But even the right number, held still, runs into the four problems below.

Why is one number wrong for most days?

Nobody walks the same amount every day. A day of errands can easily be twice a day at a desk, and a long Sunday walk can be three times a rainy Monday. Look at a month of your steps in the Health app and you'll usually see swings of several thousand from one day to the next.

A fixed goal ignores all of that. It's set for a day that rarely happens, so it lands as too hard on busy days and too easy on free ones. You end up with a goal that's only ever right by accident.

What happens when you miss your goal every day?

If your average is 4,000 steps and your goal is 10,000, you'll miss it almost every day, and missing it every day teaches you something: that the goal isn't really meant for you.

Goal-setting research has found this for decades. Hard goals push people to do more, but only as long as they still believe they can reach them. Once a goal looks out of reach, commitment drops, and so does effort. Psychologists studying diets called the next step the "what-the-hell effect": once the day's target is blown, people stop trying for the rest of the day, because a near miss feels no better than a big one. With steps, that's a 6,000-step day that could have been 7,000, and a goal you stop looking at.

It also breaks streaks. A streak is one of the most motivating things a step counter can show you, but a goal you rarely hit means a streak that never gets past two.

Why does a fixed goal stop you on good days?

On a free day, the opposite happens. You hit 10,000 by mid-afternoon, the counter says done, and the goal has nothing more to ask. A target works as a finish line, and people tend to slow down once they've crossed one.

For most people this matters less than missing every day, but it means a fixed goal holds back the days that could do the most good, and never asks you to build on them.

Why does a goal that was right go stale?

Even a well-chosen fixed goal stops fitting. If you start at 4,000 a day and set 5,000, it's a good stretch in week one. By week eight, when you're comfortably walking 6,500, it asks nothing of you. And if you get ill, injured or busy for a fortnight, the same 5,000 can suddenly feel out of reach.

Your walking changes from week to week. A goal that doesn't change with it is either behind you or too far ahead.

What does the research say about goals that adapt?

Researchers have tested fixed goals against goals that change with you, and the adapting ones have tended to win.

• Goal-setting theory. Edwin Locke and Gary Latham's review of 35 years of research found that specific, challenging goals lead to more effort than vague ones like "do your best", but only when people are committed to them and believe they can reach them. A goal that's out of reach most days fails the second test.
• Adaptive versus fixed goals. In a 2017 trial, 96 inactive adults wore a step counter for four months, with either a fixed goal of 10,000 steps or a daily goal worked out from their own recent steps. Both groups walked more at first, and the fixed-goal group a little more so. But their steps then fell away more than twice as fast, and by the end the adaptive group was ahead.
• Personalised goals in an app. In a 2018 trial of 64 adults using a step-counting app, both groups' steps slipped over ten weeks. Those given a fixed 10,000 a day lost about 1,350 steps a day. Those whose goals were set from their own walking lost about 390.

The pattern is worth noticing: a big fixed goal can work for a few weeks, while motivation is high. It's keeping going that it's bad at. These are small trials, and the differences are modest. But they point the same way as the step-count research: what matters is more walking than you do now, and a goal you can hit is how you get it.

What works better than a fixed step goal?

You don't need an algorithm to fix a fixed goal. A few rules do most of the work:

1. Start from your own average. In the Health app, open Steps and look at your daily average over the last few weeks. Your first goal is a little above that, not 10,000.
2. Raise it about 10% a week. From 4,000 steps a day, that's 4,400, then 4,800, 5,300, 5,800, 6,400 and 7,000 by the sixth week. No single week is a shock. The step goal calculator lays out every week of it for your age and average.
3. Let days differ. Give your busiest days a lower target and your free days a higher one, so the week adds up to what you're aiming for.
4. Judge the week, not the day. One short day doesn't matter if the week is on track. StepUp's Trend metric shows whether your steps are rising or slipping over weeks, which says more than any single day.
5. Hold it when it's hard. If a week was a struggle, repeat it instead of raising it. If you're ill or hurt, drop back, then build up again.
6. Keep a minimum day. Pick a small walk you'd do on your worst day, ten minutes say, and count it as a win. The beginner's walking plan builds the first weeks around one.

None of this makes the goal easier in the long run. It makes it reachable now, so it can keep growing. A goal you hit five days a week and raise every week will take you further than a 10,000 you've stopped looking at.

Does missing one day ruin the habit?

No. In the best-known study of how habits form, missing one day didn't set people back: the habit kept building once they picked it up again. What breaks a habit is a goal that makes every day feel like a miss, until you stop counting. The walking habit guide covers how to make the walk something you do without deciding to.

How does StepUp set your goal?

StepUp doesn't start everyone at 10,000. It reads your step history from Apple Health and builds a walking plan from it. Each day of the week gets its own target, so a quiet Tuesday and a busy Saturday aren't asked for the same number. Each week asks a little more, never over 10%, and ends with a recap of how it went. Your streak counts every day you hit the goal, so an honest target keeps it alive, and Routine shows how regular your walking is becoming.

All of it happens on your iPhone: your steps never leave it.

The short version

• A fixed step goal is the same number every day, and most days aren't the same.
• It's too hard on busy days, so you miss it and stop looking, and too easy on free days, so it stops you early.
• Even a good fixed goal goes stale as you get fitter or life gets busier.
• In trials, people whose goals adapted to them kept their walking up better than people given a fixed 10,000.
• Start a little above your average, raise it about 10% a week, let days differ, and judge the week rather than the day.

Written by Dheeraj Kumar Sharma, who makes StepUp. How the guides are written.